Thursday, March 1, 2007

Parents as Friends? Yay or Nay?

I would like to thank CheerfulStorm for taking the time to reply to my Liar Liar post down below. Part of me has wanted to delete that post since the moment I posted it, as it was posted in a moment of angst and frustration on my part as a parent. But, it stands. And I think rightfully so, as I am pretty sure I am only one of many parents who has to deal with the issue of lying.

The thing she said that has stuck with me the most though, really doesn't have to do with lying, well, exactly anyway. She said:

You're the Mom - not their friend

I have been contemplating this concept all afternoon. I have heard it time after time, and it seems to be sort of "age old" parenting wisdom.

But I think I disagree.

I think the best approach to parenting is not one of either/or stature- but of Both and And.

Why can we not be both a friend AND a parent to our children? And isn't that even the ideal situation between parent and child?

I suppose the biggest question one would have to ask themselves first, is what they mean by friend?

If by "friend" one means that parents should try and "fit in" with their kids, or give some false pretense of "cool" to hang out with them, then it isn't a good idea to be friends with your kid. (And I would fail from the offset at that simply for writing cool instead of kewl.)

Another bad idea might be to take being friends with your kid to mean that you lower yourself to some inappropriate level of maturity. To mean that to be a friend to my 10 year old means that I act in accordance with a ten year old's value system or maturity level.

Anyone remember the parent who thought it was cool to help all the kids skip school, or buy alcohol for all the 12 year olds on the block? yeah- that isn't a good idea of how to be friends with your kid.

But none of those definitions fit my idea of what a real friend is. When I am interacting with my friends, I am a pretty straightforward person. I tell them what I think, when it is appropriate. I give them advice when they ask for it, and sometimes when they don't. If they are stepping on my boundaries or being rude to me, I am honest and open about my feelings on the subject. This actually just happened between me and one of my best friends yesterday, and ended with an apology between us and a better understanding of each other.

Above all, I listen to what my friends are saying to me. I try and be the kind of friend that they could open up to. I help them out when they need it, and try to be someone they can count on. They call me when they need a babysitter or need help moving. We plan things together that we both enjoy, and we try and have a good time. We laugh together, and cry together.

I have friends who are much older than I am, and I look to them for that wisdom that comes from just being around longer than I have. I have friends who are a great deal younger than I am. I also feel misunderstood by them sometimes, as in "They just don't understand where I am coming from."

I would like to think that all of those statements apply to my relationships with my kids. Especially with the ones I gave birth too and that live here with me day and night. I try to achieve that level of intimacy with my stepchildren as well, but it is more of a struggle. I keep trying.

That doesn't mean that I eschew parent for friend- no way. It just makes it easier for me to parent my kids. And I think it will continue to help even more so they grow.

The bottom line is that I am the parent, and I do call the shots. I get to make a lot of decisions about what happens to my kids, and I take on the responsibility of trying to guide them into a happy and successful adulthood. But I can't imagine an existence where "friend" and "parent" happened totally in isolation from each other.

I asked my ten year old what he thought about this and his response seemed to affirm my thoughts (of course, I have had considerable influence on him). While I know that as he approaches his teen years the distance might grow between us (however, I don't consider that a given as I personally know several sets of parents/teens that are very close)- I'd like to think he could come to me to talk about the things he was going through- and that he might get an understanding and sympathetic ear from a good friend- and parent.

I know I could have used that growing up.

2 comments:

reviewer said...

I am mother AND friend. Parent first, friend second.

Veloute said...

Great post! There was a good Friend vs. Parent couple of articles in "Brain, Child" a while back (one article for, one against).

I know that sometimes we have to make choices for our kids that aren't really typical of the role of a "friend"...but that doesn't mean we completely leave that role in the dust.

Bookshelf

Shannon's currently-reading book montage

The Complete Poems
Collected Poems
Kenya: Between Hope and Despair, 1963-2011
Anti-Bias Education for young children and ourselves
I Laugh So I Won't cry: kenya's Women Tell the Stories of Their Lives
How to Be Compassionate: a Handbook for Creating Inner Peace and a Happier World
Children
The Hundred Languages of Children: The Reggio Emilia Approach Advanced Reflections
The Secret Garden


Shannon's favorite books »

Shannon's read-in-2012 book montage

Rethinking Early Childhood Education
Anti-Bias Curriculum: Tools for Empowering Young Children
Safari Animals
Young Children Reinvent Arithmetic: Implications of Piaget's theory (early childhood education series
Total Learning: Developmental Curriculum for the Young Child
Clinical Supervision and Teacher Development


Shannon's favorite books »
}