Thursday, May 1, 2008

Why I Am NOT Boycotting China Anymore, But Then Again, I Am Still Boycotting China

I have long been a proponent of framing things in a positive way for ourselves and the children we know, teach and love. I try to remind myself at all times to focus on what we do, not what we don't do. I want to live in a positive frame of mind, and I want my children in that positive place with me.

Simple examples of what I mean:
  • I want to live a healthier lifestyle. I add more fruits and vegetables to my diet, as opposed to cutting out all candy. Even better, I declare that I am going to eat 3 grapefruits a week and put absolutely no focus on what I am not eating.
  • My toddler wants to climb on the table. I ask him to keep his bottom on the chair, as opposed to telling him not to climb on the table.
  • My 11 year old wants to play play station again. I ask him to join us for a game of scrabble, or suggest he get out the art supplies, as opposed to saying no to video games.
  • We want to buy new spring clothing. We shop at the consignment stores, as opposed to not shopping at the big box stores.
It is all in phrasing and can be boiled down to semantics I suppose, but I also think it helps us train our minds to think in a more positive direction. If we focus on what we can do and not what we cannot do, we are less confused, and some things may seem like less of a burden.

What does this have to do with not boycotting China anymore?

More and more people are beginning their own versions of a "Made in China" boycott. I am surprised at the shear number of people who speak about made in China, and are increasingly frustrated with China's dominance in the consumer market. I am engaged in these conversations regularly, even with people who I am most generally politically divided with.

Our family has been focusing its attention on this type of conscious consuming for more than a year, and for many years in lesser forms. (You can read more about that here.)

While it would seem like this is a good thing, I am gravely concerned about the effect that giving adult voice to boycotting China is having on the children who are trying to understand just what we are doing, and why we are doing it.

I believe that it may be near impossible to differentiate between a boycott of a government's severe human rights abuse record and a rejection of anything Chinese, especially including people, in a young child's eyes.

Even as adults we have a hard time understanding how a people may be separate from the government of that people. Governments are made up of people, from the most powerful to the least powerful.

I am concerned that actively boycotting China is indeed subtly condoning anti-Chinese sentiment in our household.

Imagine how a very young child who is raised in a home that shuns Chinese made toys will react the first time that child understands that the child sitting across from him at preschool was born in China?

So, if I am not Boycotting China anymore, What am I doing?

Absolutely nothing different than what I was doing before, other than be more aware of what I say about it. Instead of saying, "We can't buy this toy becuase its made in China," we can say, "Let's buy the toy (shoe, shirt, grill, toothbrush) made closest to home." Instead of saying, "All of food processors are made in China so we can't buy a new one," we can say, "We are going to use this knife to chop our onions from now on."

We can still teach our children about making choices that are good for the Earth and good for humans without burdening them with difficult task of differentiating people from their governments. We can still teach them about what human rights are, without teaching them what human rights abuses are, or who is most well known for unapologetically condoning those abuses.

We can teach each other to have loving and peaceful connections with the Earth and the Earth's people.

When they are ready for the heavier work of fighting for justice, or for the sometimes necessary and difficult task of dividing people into categories of oppressor and oppressed, we will know. When they are ready, we can respond.

1 comment:

Jules said...

you are awesome Shannon!

Bookshelf

Shannon's currently-reading book montage

The Complete Poems
Collected Poems
Kenya: Between Hope and Despair, 1963-2011
Anti-Bias Education for young children and ourselves
I Laugh So I Won't cry: kenya's Women Tell the Stories of Their Lives
How to Be Compassionate: a Handbook for Creating Inner Peace and a Happier World
Children
The Hundred Languages of Children: The Reggio Emilia Approach Advanced Reflections
The Secret Garden


Shannon's favorite books »

Shannon's read-in-2012 book montage

Rethinking Early Childhood Education
Anti-Bias Curriculum: Tools for Empowering Young Children
Safari Animals
Young Children Reinvent Arithmetic: Implications of Piaget's theory (early childhood education series
Total Learning: Developmental Curriculum for the Young Child
Clinical Supervision and Teacher Development


Shannon's favorite books »
}